America’s Got Talent - Some of America, Anyway

I have a confession to make: I watch America’s Got Talent, and quite enjoy it. I know, I know - David Hasselhoff is in it, and I’m slightly embarrassed to be watching anything in which he appears. But despite his awfulness (proof thereof), it’s an entertaining show. There’s a surprising amount of people who appear on it who are genuinely talented. There’s admittedly only one winner, but perhaps those talented individuals who appear on the show will gain the exposure they need to make it big elsewhere.

It’s not, however, the talented people I’m wondering about. I’m wondering about the people who stand in a massive line of people for a whole day or more, in order to show on national television that they’re not overly talented. Or worse, that they’re just downright bad. Take, for example, this couple, who claim they’re going to wow the world with “Polka Today”, a style of dance they created. While I know very little about dance, what they’re doing does not look particularly revolutionary. Are they suppose to look so… flaily? Perhaps it was just a bluff, but the guy seems genuinely confident that their dancing will impress everyone there. Or check out this compilation video of some of the worst acts seen in this season thus far. What were these people thinking when they said, “Hey, I think I’ll try to win America’s Got Talent”? Did the Ozzy impersonator really think he sounded like Ozzy? They showed his closing remarks on the show (not included in the above video), and he, too, seemed to feel that he was genuinely good.

I’m sure some people who go on the show just do it to be a goof; they know they have no real talent, and that they have no real chance of winning. They do it to for laughs, to say “look at me, I’m on TV!” But it really does seem that a lot of the folks who are just bad think they’ve got what it takes to win the competition. Are their talent radar machines broken? I suppose tone deafness might explain some of the awful singers, but what of the magicians who drop their cards, lose their birds, and fall to the floor when they try to “levitate”? The lady who tried to rap, while jumping up and down on big shards of broken glass? The lady who crushed a sack full of soda cans with her enormous breasts?

What’s up with these people? The show is American’s Got Talent, folks, not American’s Got Crazy People. (Not to imply that we don’t have our fair share of those, mind you…)

Tags: ,

I really do love casting shows, but I think the judges are always so terrible - in the USA, in Great Britain, in Germany. The TV stations do their best to find the meanest B-celebrities for these shows. Why do they have to be so cruel? Take for example the polka dancers: Everybody laughed at them - which I think is completely okay. But is it really necessary that the judges insult them?

We recently had two casting shows (one for singin, one for acting) here in Germany that were different. Of course everybody still laughed about the crazy people, who thought they where talented but weren’t. But the judges treated them with respect, they didn’t insult the people or their personality, they only made fun about the performances. It was a pleasure to watch, really.

Well, I think part of the reason the judges get a bit snippy with bad contestants is related to what I mentioned above: not only are they bad, but they can be rather cocky and kind of obstinate. After watching them flailing about, I’d probably be a bit irritated too when the guy got all defensive and put out. Also, I think it’s just become standard procedure to get a “nice” judge, a “neutral” judge, and a “bad” judge. Maybe this started with American Idol with Simon (I’ve never watched A.I., but I’ve heard Simon was a real arse).

I’d also argue that the judges are instructed to act a certain way, so as to have certain dynamics between them. Piers on America’s Got Talent can be quite a jerk when responding to bad contestants, but in the behind the scenes stuff, he comes across as a very nice guy.

We have our own “arse” here: Dieter Bohlen. The channel had to pay 100000 Euro fine for what he said on the last season of Germany’s Idol. :-)

But really: The judges should get snippy with the show staff. These casting shows always have pre-castings, where other people chose the good ones and some really bad ones - to make the show funny. These people are invited to come again a week later in the same clothes and perform in front of the real jury.

This also explains, why the bad candidates can be obstinate: They think they are really good, because they’ve already made it through the pre-casting. It’s reminds me a little bit of wrestling…. Everything is pre-arranged.