I’ve been reflecting on a trait I have, or perhaps one would say problem, and how I might get rid of it. What’s the problem? I have a hell of a time sticking to some things, despite how badly I’d like to be successful. I’ll think of something I want to do, or something I think I should do, and decide: alright, I’m going to do this. The motive is there, the intention is there, the will is there. The will ultimately disappears, however, and I’m not quite sure where the little bugger is getting off to.
I posted a little under a year ago about being in a Buddhist meditation group. The group has since had some problems in getting together, mostly due to scheduling conflicts between us. It’s amazing how difficult it can be to get 3-4 people together in one place for an hour… but I digress. What of my own daily meditation, which I had been doing at the time? Good question. I’m not sure what happened. My zafu and zabuton are still set up in my room, but I’ve sat down there once in months (a few days ago). Why? I just can’t bring myself to do it every day. I still want to, and I have the time, but when it comes around to doing it, something in my head just says “meh”, and I go do something else. And then the next day rolls around, I think “I should meditate”, and yet I don’t.
The same thing happened with my attempt at a health reboot. I had started keeping tabs on what I was eating, and I was exercising daily. And then I slipped, and then slipped again, and then I just fell back into the habits I’d had before: not exercising, eating generally like crap, and feeling bad about it the whole time. I’ve recently tried to get back into exercising, but it’s been a rather halting start. I’ve had more off days than on days, and unless that flips around, I’ll probably quit altogether. It was easy for me to start, as I found a form of exercise that I genuinely enjoy: kickboxing. I got into it, even going so far as to buy a punching bag (and to go to the considerable bother of hanging the thing, which was more difficult than I had anticipated.) But starting and staying the course are proving, of course, to be two different things. I’ve had the bag for around three weeks now, and it’s been used on 4 or 5 times. That’s not going to cut it.
So what’s the deal?
That’s the million dollar question, right? Well, here’s the problem: apparently, I’m human. Really. I did some googling on changing habits, and found that what I’m struggling with is pretty common. “Good habits are hard to develop but easy to live with, bad habits are easy to develop but hard to live with” is a quote from Brian Tracey, a motivational speaker, and is perhaps the shortest and clearest summation of what I’m struggling with. The cliché “humans are creatures of habit” is a cliché for a reason, after all. We get stuck in our ways and often, it takes more than just brute willpower to change them.
Leo at Zen Habits (love the blog name) has a good post on things to avoid when changing habits, which of course is full of things I’ve been doing when attempting these changes. And I do mean full - I think I’m guilty of every single thing on his list. Probably the biggest thing I’m guilty of is not maintaining accountability. I posted here in the past about exercising, about meditation, and then said nothing more of it. In “real life” (whatever the frak that means anymore, right?), I was also pretty quiet about my intentions to change myself. Certainly, my wife knew, my mom knew, but I hadn’t really talked to them in depth about my goals. It was more like, out of the blue, I said “oh, by the way, I’m going to exercise / meditate / whatever every day, poke me if you notice I’m not doing so, mmkay?” I’m sure they responded in the positive, and then soon after forgot about me ever having said anything
But, that’s not really their problem. It’s not their responsibility, or anyone else’s for that matter, to make me accountable. I have to do that. I’m not really sure how I’m going to do that for my exercising and meditation, though. I could certainly post about it here, but every day? Doubtful on that. Twitter? Maybe, but there’s an awful lot of noise on Twitter, so I’m not really sure anyone would notice if I didn’t post a tweet of “exercised for the day” or whatever. Leo made a training blog to help keep him accountable, but I’m not really sure if I want to go that route; I’ve already got two blogs, and if I make a blog for every habit I wish to make or change… well, I don’t have that much time to blog! Perhaps I’ll just talk to the family again, in more depth, and ask them to make me give a report each day. Or I could put up a calendar somewhere (the fridge would be wonderfully clichéd but practical), and mark the days I did whatever it is I’m wanting to be doing. I’ll think on it some more.
But, like I said, I’m guilty of more than just not keeping myself accountable for my goals. After reading Leo’s post, I realize that I’ve been failing pretty much everytime because when I’ve tried to change my habits, it’s been a rather spur of the moment “hey, I’m gonna’ do this!” sort of thing, with little no planning. I never wrote down any plan, especially nothing specific; I didn’t think about obstacles, I was just going to do it, by the gods! And we see how well that goes. No meditation in more or less months, and my newfound kickboxing routine quickly disappearing into that pile of vague memories which start with “Hey, I remember when I tried doing that…”
So, the gameplan: keep Leo’s list of “things to avoid” in mind, while I figure out how I’m going to go about making a 30 minute meditation session and a 30-45 minute exercise session part of my daily routine. But as per his advice, one of those is going on the shelf for a bit; you’re not supposed to tackle two habits at once
More on this after I’ve thought about it some more and done a bit more research. And if you’ve not seen anything on this blog within a few weeks about this, call me on it. All of ya’.

8 comments
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link
http://system13.org/2008/05/24/me-versus-making-new-habits/trackback/
June 23, 2008 at 10:24 pm
Pingback from An Exercise Update - Hey, What’s That White Dust? · System 13
May 25, 2008 at 2:45 am
Edrei
Guilt is irrelevant. Sometimes the best things in life to do are those that we need to do and want to do. Doing things out of anything else but our own desire to do them will only be painful, wasteful and meaningless.
If you want to do what you need to do, you’ll find a good way around to do them regardless of what stands in your way. Even if you haven’t a single inkling and even if make so many mistakes along the way. You trust yourself to see it through.
I guess that’s how I’ve lead my life. Changing habits or making new ones regardless depends on how much I wanted to change. They stuck because I want them to stick. I guess I didn’t think of whether or not I’ll go back to what was before. I just…went with the flow.
May 25, 2008 at 1:19 pm
Josh
Man, I wish I worked like that! Despite how bad I’ve wanted to make these things habits, when I’ve tried to make them habits by just “wanting to do it” and going with the flow, I always flow right back to my former habits
May 27, 2008 at 1:36 am
Tom
I’m convinced that to form new habits only bruteforce willpower and constant present-mindedness will work. You have to be consciously making the right choice every second of every minute, that requires a constant awareness of the present moment. The willpower is the actual force that will make that right choice at each one of those seconds.
That’s the only way I’ve ever succeeded. Every time I tried to trick myself by some fancy tactic, I could always reason my way out of it. However, when I took the range of possible choices and label one “success” and all of the rest “failure”, then constantly asked myself if I want to succeed or fail, the choices become easy after that. It’s kind of like passing the buck onto the higher philosophical level, it stops becoming an issue about a specific habit and turns into a desire for success.
That’s how I do it. Though that probably doesn’t make sense to anyone else :).
Good luck mate. As I always say, at least your aware of your place in this web of desires and shortcomings, which is more than can be said for many people who don’t even give their life a second look. Not being perfect is what we all suffer from, knowing about it though, is a step in the right direction.
May 27, 2008 at 11:41 pm
Josh
Tom: I like the idea of looking at choices labeled as either “success” or “failure”; it makes things a bit more clear cut. Of course, there’s lots of gray in life, but when it comes to being healthier, there’s really no way to say that exercising is a failure and sitting on your arse reading feeds is a success.
I think I may start a quote notebook / text file, and that’ll be the first one in it.
May 29, 2008 at 3:51 pm
LearningNerd
I’m struggling with the same problem, especially with habits that are not daily. And I just now ran across a new article by Steve Pavlina: How to Maintain Not-Quite-Daily Habits. He writes some good stuff!
Anyway, I find that my problem is thinking about things too much, rather than just doing them. Like trying to wake up early. The alarm wakes me up, I got enough sleep, but then I think, “It’d be so nice to sleep just a bit longer! Do I really need to get up now?” The only way to do it is to jump out of bed and start the day, without second thoughts.
But how to actually stop yourself from thinking… That’s the problem!
May 29, 2008 at 3:53 pm
Nils Geylen
Oh dear, oh dear. I’m so the same… I have this “abandonitis” with posting, commenting, exercising, getting a driver’s license, quitting smoking, planning things, planning *less* things… You catch my drift.
I do fear Tom is right, though. You have to be merciless, in your motivation and towards your own behaviour.
Oh, and I’m also bad at reminding others what they were supposed to do. So, if I don’t call you on it, you call me on it okay?
May 29, 2008 at 4:37 pm
Josh
LearningNerd: Thanks for the link on that, will definitely check it out. I’ve read Steve Pavlina’s stuff in the past; some I liked, some was a little bit out there.
Me, I’m not guilty of thinking too much. Never. At least, I don’t think so. Well, maybe. I’ll have to think about it…
I’ve never really had an issue with getting up early. Whenever I set the alarm for, I generally get up immediately after it goes off. It’s making myself go to bed that’s the problem.
Nils: Abandonitis. Duly noted and stolen for later use.
And yeah, I think Tom’s right. Environment and planning is going to play a role in my habits, but alas, there’s still got to be a fair amount of “damnit, Josh, get up and do this.”
So, lemme’ get this straight. If I slack off on exercising, I’m supposed to remind you to remind me to stay with it?
As you said: oh dear.