Lorelle posted a new blog challenge, and the challenge is this: who would you like to see blog from history?
Some of the answers that Lorelle proposed were:
Irving Stone, Issac Asimov, Tolkien, Mark Twain, and Agatha Christie? Or philosophers and scientists like Plato, Socrates, Newton, and Einstein? Famous kings, presidents, rulers?
I have to admit - these answers don’t excite me much. The benefit of having access to a blog written by someone from the past would be that we would gain access to their thoughts and ideas, right? If that’s the case, why would you want to have access to a blog written by someone who is already widely published? From someone who is already known throughout the world? Granted, not all famous kings, presidents, and rulers have left written records of their thoughts (although many have); but Tolkien? Plato? Twain? We know many of the thoughts of these people - it’s why they’re famous! None of them wrote blogs per se, but quite a few of them published copious amounts of material. And, while I can’t speak for the rest of them, there is indeed a “blog” of sorts by Tolkien: the Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien. The vast majority of the letters in it would not seem strange at all as blog posts. I realize that it’s not exactly a blog, but I think it’s close enough to make the comparison.
I am, of course, not saying that I wouldn’t enjoy reading blogs written by already famous people. I think having blogs from leaders throughout history would be fascinating. I’d pay a pretty penny to read blogs by various kings throughout the medieval age, not to mention a few key leaders during the 20th century. I think a blog written by FDR would be interesting, and one written by Hitler useful, simply to see just exactly what he was thinking as the war went on. It’s clear that the gears upstairs started breaking down as things progressed.
I think, however, what would be more interesting to read, would be blogs written by people who have been swallowed up by theĀ proverbial ocean of time. Blogs written by people who might have had important or intriguing things to say, but never had the chance. People who took part in great projects, but never were able to leave their opinion on it. People that we don’t know a great deal about.
Take, for example, one of the thousands of Egyptians who helped build the pyramids. What was it like? How many hours per day did they work? Were they paid? Did they enjoy the work, or hate it? What was their home life like after they’d finished spending a day moving enormously heavy blocks of stone?
Or how about some nameless peasant during the middle ages? Wouldn’t it be interesting to get his take on his village? His country? The world (as he knew it)? Or how about one of the countless men in the medieval hierarchy, but not at the top of it (i.e., a king or the Pope)? Say, a knight, halfway up the totem pole? Or, you could even seek out a military view. Blogs written by men and women in the military are pretty normal today, and provide a look at things from their point of view. Wouldn’t it be interesting to read a blog written by some English fellow serving as a longbow-man in a king’s army?
I personally think that those blogs would be more interesting than a blog written by someone the world already knows about, because those blogs would provide new information and new views. We have plenty of examples of the view from the position of a king or President, of a great writer or a famous thinker. It would be nice to be able to jump back in history and get a detailed view, complete with opinions, ideas and emotions, from someone who wasn’t at the top of the ladder. The “average Joe” of an ancient society.
So, in answer to Lorelle’s question: I want to see a blog written not by someone we know about, but someone we know nothing about. The man or woman who lived their life and died without leaving so much as a note saying, “Hey, this was my name”, let alone a journal, a book, a piece of art. I think that would be far more useful and interesting than a blog written by someone that we already have heaps of information on.

5 comments
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link
http://system13.org/2007/05/29/who-would-i-like-to-see-blog-from-history/trackback/
May 30, 2007 at 2:55 am
tony
Thank you for your article
May 30, 2007 at 5:31 pm
Fig
Very eloquently said, Josh. I’d have to agree with you.
May 31, 2007 at 8:12 am
Josh
tony: Uhh, you’re welcome? I’d like to make it clear that I don’t want this article to appear on articlepark.org…
Fig: Thanks.
May 31, 2007 at 12:18 pm
Lorelle
I agree totally. While it would be fascinating to look into the minds of the famous, the not-famous interest me equally. The voices never heard through time but we live with their choices, decisions, and actions today.
When you mentioned Hitler, I wondered if we’d really read what he was thinking as much as his manipulative propaganda - what he wanted you to think he was thinking. That would be more likely, and certainly reflects on how some bloggers blog today, doesn’t it?
One of the reasons the Dead Sea Scrolls fascinates me is not the evidence supporting biblical claims, but the journals in the scrolls about the day to day life of how these people lived, behaved, governed themselves, and existed. So I’m with you on this. Great point.
August 13, 2007 at 9:53 pm
Johnny Relentless
Great post!
But I don’t think Hitler would have anything more to say, that he hadn’t already said many times, loudly and often.
I would like to hear from Moses, David and Solomon, if they even existed. I would like to know if they really wrote the works that are attributed to them, if they really spoke with God, and what they think about what people have done with their teachings.
I’d also like to hear from the guy who discovered fire, the guy who invented the wheel and the guy who decided to come down from the trees. I bet the first two are wishing they had invented the patent office first! Were primitive, stone-age, Da Vincis and Einsteins by today’s standards? Or would they seem stupid compared to a modern-day human? How many stone-age geniuses lived and died, their inventions dying out with their tribes, long before patent offices and other ways to communicate ideas (such as language, or even roads to other tribes).